UN accused of allowing Assad regime to censor Syria humanitarian aid plan

NGOs have written a letter to the UN undersecretary for humanitarian affairs saying the move set 'an unacceptable precedent'

Caroline Mortimer
Friday 22 January 2016 20:51 GMT
Comments
A toddler is held up to the camera in this still image taken from video said to have been shot in Madaya, Syria
A toddler is held up to the camera in this still image taken from video said to have been shot in Madaya, Syria (Reuters)

The United Nations has been accused of altering a key humanitarian aid plan after consulting with the Assad regime.

A leaked copy of the original draft of the Syria Humanitarian Response Plan shows UN officials deleted references to “besieged” areas such as Madaya where the Assad regime blocked food and aid from getting through, Buzzfeed News has revealed.

It also removed any mentions of a programme to remove landmines, unexploded bombs and missiles, and references to the Assad regime’s alleged human rights law violations.

UN insiders and NGOs have accused the organisation of pandering to the regime and allowing itself to be censored.

A group of Syrian NGOs wrote a letter to Stephen O’Brien, the UN undersecretary for humanitarian affairs, saying they were “alarmed” by the revelations and said that it set “an unacceptable precedent”.

He said: “While we recognise the need to engage the Government of Syria, they should be treated as a party to the conflict and should not exert any greater influence over the humanitarian response than any other party.

“We are outraged that the humanitarian leadership agreed to major changes in the HRP document without engaging - or even informing - key partners”.

Aid reaches starving Madaya

The final draft report was agreed on by NGOs and UN offices in December then sent to the Syrian government for consultation.

The document was then supposed to be sent back to the UN’s Turkey and Jordan teams so they could review the changes but allegedly this did not happen.

Instead sources told Buzzfeed News the government’s requested changes were made and the document was published without further input from the NGOs.

It comes as food and aid finally reached Madaya after a six month blockage by Syrian government forces.

The Assad regime finally gave permission for the United Nations and the Syrian Arab Red Crescent to enter the city earlier this month after an international outcry.

At a press conference last week, the UN’s Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said the situation in Madaya showed “shocking depths of inhumanity”.

He said UN staff who had entered the city had described “the elderly and children, men and women, who were little more than skin and bones: gaunt, severely malnourished, so weak they could barely walk, and utterly desperate for the slightest morsel.”

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in