Sign up to our free sport newsletter for all the latest news on everything from cycling to boxing Sign up to our free sport email for all the latest news
World Cup winner Dan Carter would not be out of place in the All Blacks squad at the global showpiece in Japan later this year if selectors sent him an SOS to fill the gap left by the injured Damian McKenzie , former coach Graham Henry has said.
Utility back McKenzie was ruled out of rugby for the rest of the year earlier this week after he ruptured an ACL knee tendon, scuppering Steve Hansen's plans to take him to the World Cup where he could cover fullback and flyhalf.
Beauden Barrett and Richie Mo'unga were expected to be the specialist flyhalves in Hansen's World Cup squad but McKenzie's injury has revealed a lack of depth behind the trio.
"There's been some talk about Dan Carter and I don't think Dan Carter will let you down," Henry told radio station Newstalk ZB. "He would be number three and I think he fits comfortably in that position.
"He'll add a huge amount of experience and intellectual property about the Rugby World Cup and playing international rugby. He's been there and done that."
England vs New Zealand player ratingsShow all 30 1 /30England vs New Zealand player ratings England vs New Zealand player ratings Ben Moon - 7 out of 10 Certainly strengthened England’s scrum from the get-go and looked comfortable at this level against seasoned opposition in Owen Franks. Replaced just shy of the hour by Alec Hepburn.
Action Images via Reuters
England vs New Zealand player ratings Dylan Hartley - 7 out of 10 One overthrow on the first half but took the plaudits for the team shove-over try. Departed at half-time with a thumb injury, and England’s lineout completely malfunctioned without him as it went from 100 per cent completion to less than half.
REUTERS
England vs New Zealand player ratings Kyle Sinckler - 7 out of 10 Another bone-crunching tackle, this week on Goodhue, set the tone for the defence although he was guilty of another first-half scrum infringement. Got sucked into the ‘big-player’ knack of seeing a smaller man and running at him, as Barrett impressively halted his barrelling run.
AFP/Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Maro Itoje - 7 out of 10 A much-improved disciplinary performance as he took on the duty of being England’s go-to man in the lineout. A defensive rock in the line and caused problems for Aaron Smith as he pressured the scrum-half.
EPA
England vs New Zealand player ratings George Kruis - 6 out of 10 Struggled to make as much of an impact this week with his carrying, and the lineout misfunction in the second half is part of his responsibility as caller. Left the field with a knock in the 67th minute.
AFP/Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Brad Shields - 6 out of 10 Forced off early for an HIA that he returned from just before the break and showed a bit of niggle against his former teammates. Replaced permanently by Lawes with 15 minutes remaining.
PA
England vs New Zealand player ratings Sam Underhill - 8 out of 10 Led the defensive charge with good line speed, but missed a tackle on Crotty in the seconds before McKenzie’s try. Kept England in the the hunt in the second half and secured a crucial turnover on England’s 5m line to prevent a try.
Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Mark Wilson - 7 out of 10 Phenomenal work rate in defence but facing New Zealand showed up his lack of ball carrying a bit more this weekend.
EPA
England vs New Zealand player ratings Ben Youngs - 7 out of 10 Good awareness to spot Ashton unmarked and feed him with a lovely miss-pass for the first try. His best performance this season by far, but his poor chip into Read’s hands proved to be his last contribution as Danny Care came on.
AFP/Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Owen Farrell - 7 out of 10 Stripped Savea of the ball early on and pulled all the strings for his side. Smart move to the openside created the space for Ashton’s try before he added a drop-goal, and also dislodged the ball with his tackle on McKenzie when the full-back had rounded Daly. Only criticism can be the missed touchline conversion for Ashton’s score.
EPA
England vs New Zealand player ratings Jonny May - 7 out of 10 Enjoyed one mazy run in the second half that reignited England’s fight as he came into the line off Farrell’s inside shoulder, and popped up across the park as he upped his usual work-rate.
Rex Features
England vs New Zealand player ratings Ben Te’o - 6 out of 10 Eddie Jones warned that this would prove a much harder task for him and so it proved. Unable to make much impact with the ball in hand and caught out of position for McKenzie’s try.
AFP/Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Henry Slade - 7 out of 10 Displayed a few lovely touches that kept the All Blacks defence guessing, not least when he wrongfooted Goodhue in the first half before chipping in behind.
AFP/Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Chris Ashton - 7 out of 10 Given all the time he needed by smart play from the England back line to slide in for the opening try after two minutes. Faded thereafter as the All Blacks started to control possession, and replaced by Jack Nowell midway through the second half.
Action Images via Reuters
England vs New Zealand player ratings Elliot Daly - 6 out of 10 Brilliant piece of play to keep a Barrett penalty kick in play. A much-improved performance under the high ball in testing conditions, though he did lose one early one with a knock-on.
PA
England vs New Zealand player ratings Karl Tu'inukuafe - 7 out of 10 Stood up well against Sinckler and eked out a penalty in the opening 40 minutes, though didn’t make a great impact carrying-wise.
Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Codie Taylor - 7 out of 10 Strong work in the lineout and with a player like Dane Coles waiting on the bench, he needs to maintain his performance to keep his place in the side.
PA
England vs New Zealand player ratings Owen Franks - 6 out of 10 Fairly quiet and wasn’t able to get at Moon as much as he would have hoped, resulting in his early departure in the 44th minute.
Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Sam Whitelock - 7 out of 10 Played a strong leadership role alongside Read and put in a solid shift with a full 80 minutes. Played a role in disrupting England’s lineout too.
Action Images via Reuters
England vs New Zealand player ratings Brodie Retallick - 8 out of 10 Dropped the kick-off to give England an immediate lift, but minute No 2 he was sublime and tore the England lineout to shreds in the second half with three steals as he got at Jamie George.
Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Liam Squire - 5 out of 10 Anonymous around the breakdown and carrying and while he defended well, it was far from his best performance.
AP
England vs New Zealand player ratings Ardie Savea - 6 out of 10 Lost the ball when tackled by Farrell, but a strong turnover later in the first half made up for his mistake. Should have scored a try straight after the restart but that was more to do with Smith’s poor pass.
Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Kieran Read - 7 out of 10 Felt the power of Lawes when he was smashed on the try line by the England replacement seconds before McKenzie’s try, but made an impact of his own with a barrelling run that flattened Farrell.
AP
England vs New Zealand player ratings Aaron Smith - 6 out of 10 Wasn’t given the time and space he craves as England did a good job of shutting him down, and it was his poor pass to Savea that butchered a certain try.
Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Beauden Barrett - 6 out of 10 Shaky start saw him fail to collect a high ball and kick rather erratically from hand. As the rain died down he grew into the game and created McKenzie’s try nicely, but then gave away a penalty late on that nearly cost New Zealand the game. In the end, it was his points that won the match, but it was very much a hit and miss display.
Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Rieko Ioane - 6 out of 10 Kept relatively quiet in the first half as England starved the All Blacks of ball, even more anonymous in the second half as England did a good job of putting the ball behind him.
AFP/Getty Images
England vs New Zealand player ratings Sonny Bill Williams - 4 out of 10 His first chance to get his hands on the ball and take aim at the England defence didn’t come until the 18th minute, and the back-line was very much disjointed with him in it before injury forced his departure on the half-hour mark.
Action Images via Reuters
England vs New Zealand player ratings Jack Goodhue - 5 out of 10 Got to know Sinckler a bit better than he’d have wanted to, and disappointed as he struggled to get on the ball.
Action Images via Reuters
England vs New Zealand player ratings Ben Smith - 6 out of 10 One good break down the right in the first half and made a lovely second-half break through the midfield that went unrewarded when Savea dropped the ball with the line at his mercy.
AP
England vs New Zealand player ratings Damian McKenzie - 6 out of 10 Peppered with high ball early on in the wet conditions. Hit into touch by Ashton to concede possession that led to the first try, but grew into the game and ran a smart line on Barrett’s shoulder to get the try before half-time. Guilty in the second half of kicking the ball straight into touch to invite pressure but cut a lovely line off Read’s offload, only to drop the ball in the tackle from Farrell.
AFP/Getty Images
Carter, a three-times World Player of the Year, retired from internationals after his 112th test when he helped the All Blacks to the 2015 Rugby World Cup title but continued to play club rugby in France and Japan.
Henry, however, acknowledged that Carter's return was a long shot.
The 37-year-old recently underwent neck surgery which cost him a lucrative short-term return to France.
He is also not currently contracted to New Zealand Rugby, which excludes him from selection as the All Blacks have a firm policy of picking only locally-based players.
"It's just obvious they have to qualify and they have to be playing and signed in this country to be available for the All Blacks," Henry said.
"I'm sure he'll be good for Beaudy and Richie if he was there. And who knows? But it sounds like there's a lot of work going on behind the scenes."
Carter is not the only former player being mentioned as a potential candidate with local media reporting that Aaron Cruden could leave Montpellier and return home on a short-term contract before joining former Super Rugby coach Dave Rennie at Glasgow.
The 50-test veteran left New Zealand after the 2017 British and Irish Lions Tour to play in France but has struggled to assert himself in Europe.
Reuters
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies