Chris Grayling refuses to resign over ferry contract fiasco after being branded ‘off the Richter scale of incompetence’
Transport secretary told he is ‘rewriting the textbook on ministerial incompetence’ amid row over Seaborne Freight deal
A defiant Chris Grayling has refused to resign as transport secretary as he came under fire for handing a government ferry contract to a company that does not own any ferries.
The cabinet minister defended his decision to award the £13.8m deal to Seaborne Freight, despite being forced to scrap the contract after saying the company’s major backer had pulled its support.
Labour called on the beleaguered minister to quit, accusing him of “rewriting the textbook for ministerial incompetence”.
The government’s decision to hand one of three no-deal Brexit ferry contracts to Seaborne sparked a major row in December when it emerged that the firm did not own any ships.
Mr Grayling defended the move at the time but cancelled the deal last week after Irish company Arklow Shipping withdrew its support.
Asking an urgent question in the Commons on the issue, Andy McDonald, Labour’s shadow transport secretary, said: “What began as a debacle has now descended into a Whitehall farce. This minister is rewriting the textbook for ministerial incompetence in office.”
He added: “He simply can’t keep blaming others for his own mistakes – this disastrous decision sits squarely with him and with his office.
“Isn’t it the case that his approach to transport and wider Brexit contingency planning is off the Richter scale of incompetence and for the good of the nation, and for the sake of some semblance of faith being restored to this shambolic government, shouldn’t he now at long last do the decent thing and go?”
Mr Grayling hit back, claiming Mr McDonald “brings a new meaning to the words utter hogwash”.
He told MPs that his department was “fully aware” that Seaborne was a “startup business” but that the firm’s plans for establishing a ferry route between Ramsgate and Ostend had been backed by Arklow.
He insisted that “not a penny of taxpayers’ money has gone or will go to Seaborne” and said the decision to award the ferry contracts as part of preparations for a no-deal Brexit was “a responsible decision to make sure that taxpayers’ money is properly protected”.
The SNP also called on Mr Grayling to resign. Its transport spokesperson, Alan Brown, asked: “Given a stunning new level of incompetence which it’s really hard to achieve, when will he go?”
As the transport secretary faced heavy criticism in the Commons, Labour’s Angela Eagle added: “Last month the minister came to this house waxing lyrical about how he was going to be supporting startup businesses, and this was Seaborne Freight.
“Is he not even remotely embarrassed that this has fallen to pieces, despite the government’s support, and isn’t he going to come to the house and say sorry for the mess he’s made of this?”
Mr Grayling responded: “This is a startup business that didn’t succeed because its principal backer changed its mind. That is to be regretted, it is a great shame, but I am never going to make an apology for government trying to work with new small businesses.”
The decision to award the contract to Seaborne sparked further mockery last month when it emerged that the company had copied the terms and conditions on its website from a takeaway outlet.
The government is also facing a lawsuit over the process that led to the deals being awarded.
Channel Tunnel operator Eurotunnel has launched a challenge at the High Court, claiming the contracts were awarded after a “secretive and flawed procurement process”.
The Department for Transport insisted that the “extreme urgency” of preparations for a no-deal Brexit meant the rapid process was necessary.
We’ll tell you what’s true. You can form your own view.
At The Independent, no one tells us what to write. That’s why, in an era of political lies and Brexit bias, more readers are turning to an independent source. Subscribe from just 15p a day for extra exclusives, events and ebooks – all with no ads.