You’d think all cans now open with ring-pulls, but you can guarantee it’ll be that essential ingredient that comes in a good old-fashioned closed tin. Every utensil drawer should have a can opener, and as we’ll see here, they don’t have to be unwieldy monsters that cause cans to jam open.

Smooth gears and a sharp, piercing blade are essential for smooth opening, and all those we tested delivered the goods. We took a variety of tins, including more awkward, large or flat-shaped ones and put them to the test with a panel of hungry teens, kitchen gadget fans and older people who admitted opening cans could often be a struggle.

Some of the manual can openers were as easy to use as the electric or battery-operated versions, and we particularly liked anything that held its tin top in place until it was time to jettison. No one wants bean juice on their fingers, after all.

Joseph Joseph Can-Do Opener: £16, Joseph Joseph

Place this handy gadget on top of your can and give the large handle a twist. It locks on immediately and cuts with ease. We loved its compact form because it fit into the kitchen drawer neatly and the fact the tin top drops straight in the recycling when you pop the side button.

Buy now

Judge Electric Can Opener: £18.50, Harts of Stur

A must for anyone who struggles to hold and twist handles or with piercing the tin when using a handheld gadget. One quick whirr on this plug-in wonder and there’s an open can with its lid held separately by a magnet. There’s a bonus bottle opener underneath and a useful knife sharpener on the back, too.

Buy now

Kitchencraft Butterfly Can Opener: £1.79, Lakeland

This iconic shape has been around since the 1920s and may be basic but, suitably, does exactly what it says on the tin. Squeeze the legs together to pierce the top of the can, then twist the butterfly handle to rotate the cutting edge around it. The nifty handle end opens bottle tops too. This is a worthy classic.

Buy now

Chef’n EZ Squeeze One Handed Can Opener: £13, John Lewis & Partners

This model uses a clever ratchet system to open the tin, so simply by squeezing the handle together a few times, the rotating cutter will go through the rim with the use of only one hand. Our tester loved the way it angled the tin lid upwards when finished, meaning she could pour the contents straight into a pan while still being held by the gadget.

Buy now

Culinaire Advanced One-Touch Can Opener: £20, Dunelm

Clamp this clever opener to the top of the can, press the button and it will move itself round the rim, opening as it goes. The lid stays attached by magnets when you lift off again. Takes a couple of AA batteries, which click easily into the pebble-shaped casing.

Buy now

Hoorwood Stellar Sure Grip Can Opener: £14, Horwood

Nicely chunky but not too heavy, this is another good choice for those with more limited mobility. Cutting smoothly through tins, the handles are soft-touch and comfy to grip, while the sharp blade cuts smoothly through the tin with minimum effort.

Buy now

Ikea Stam Can Opener: £1.75, Ikea

A bargain price for such a good looking kitchen essential. This comes in red, white or black and although most of the components are plastic, for the price it’s still a pretty robust piece of kit. The handles clip together neatly when not in use, so it doesn’t take up much room in the utensil’s drawer and it’s suitable for right or left-handed use.

Buy now

OXO Good Grips Can Opener: £10, Amazon

This is not the most compact opener out there, but it’s the sturdy design that makes it so easy to handle. You can rely on the Good Grips range to be comfortable and great quality and this doesn’t disappoint, piercing the tin and moving around its edge with ease. The only downside is it’s hand wash only.

Buy now

Victorinox Spartan Pocket Knife: £18.89, Amazon

Back in 1890, the Swiss government ordered thousands of knives from Victorinox for army use. There were two essential functions – a screwdriver for dismantling weaponry and a basic can opener for tackling food supplies. All these years later, pop a Spartan on your keyring and you need never look longingly at an unopened Fray Bentos pie again. Puncture a hole then wiggle the curved blade up and down round the can – easy, once you get the hang of it.

Buy now

The verdict: Can openers

For ease of use, no mess and great storage, Joseph Joseph’s Can-Do is our winner. There’s a lot to be said for KitchenCrafts’ bargain classic too – of it was good enough for Granny, it’s good enough for us.

IndyBest product reviews are unbiased, independent advice you can trust. On some occasions, we earn revenue if you click the links and buy the products, but we never allow this to bias our coverage. The reviews are compiled through a mix of expert opinion and real-world testing.