IM Subscribe Now IM Subscribe Now

8 best eyebrow pencils

Create a high-brow look with a vital make-up accessory

Getty iStock

Whether thanks to genetics or over-plucking during your teens, most people need a little assistance to achieve those oh-so-trendy, luscious, Cara Delevingne brows. 

For maximum control and a delicate touch, we prefer to fill in with short upward strokes with an eyebrow pencil – and these are some of our favourites.

From the classic pencil to creamier angled applicators, plus built-in sharpeners, spoolies (those eyebrow brushes that look like mascara brushes), highlighters and other clever add-ons, there's sure to be something here that suits the look – and ease of application – you're after.

Just remember the first rule of brows: always draw them on in bright, natural light to avoid the OTT, unnatural look.

1. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz: £15.50, Cult Beauty

This is something of a cult product and gives brilliant results at a very reasonable price. Available in the biggest range we've seen – 10 shades – it is loved by make-up artists including Kenneth Soh for its buildable, feather-light coverage thanks to the precision applicator and soft-but-not-too-soft formula.

Buy now

2. Charlotte Tilbury Brow Lift: £22.50, Charlotte Tilbury 

You can always rely on Charlotte Tilbury to produce nail-hitting products, including this brow pencil, which is creamy but light so very natural. It has a thick, angled nib for easy filling and swooping over the arch of the brow, a spoolie for shaping and blending and a built-in highlighter for defining under the brows too. Available in five shades.

Buy now

3. Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil: £20, Benefit

For absolute precision, the narrow nib of Benefit's twist-up (no sharpener required!) pencil is perfect for drawing individual hairs and is somehow soft enough to not drag on the skin, but is also smudge-proof and waterproof. Available in six shades.

Buy now

4. YSL Dessin Des Sourcils Eyebrow Pencil: £21, YSL Beauty

This is the most classic of all the pencils we tested and gets the job done without the fancy additions of other brands. The pencil is very soft and kohl-like, easily blended if you go a little heavy, and available in four shades.

Buy now

5. Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil: £29, Space.NK

Hourglass's pencil comes in its signature rich metal packaging, which feels luxe and pleasantly weighty in your hand. Its angled, thick nib (similar to Charlotte Tilbury's) is a mix of powder and wax, meaning it's not at all harsh and helps to tame unruly hairs. Available in nine shades.

Buy now

6. DiorShow Brow Styler: £20, John Lewis

This application takes a little time, designed as it is to draw individual hairs with a wind-up precision nib, but its natural finish is perfect for those who hate the coloured-in look. It comes in four shades (including a very natural auburn) and has a spoolie in the end for brushing and shaping. 

Buy now

7. Estee Lauder The Brow Multitasker: £21.50, Estee Lauder

Estee Lauder's offering is, as the name suggests, something of a multi-tasker. It has an angled pen, which goes on gently with no pulling on the skin, plus an applicator loaded with powder for filling on the reverse and a spoolie. In five shades from blonde to black.

Buy now

8. Mac Big Brow Pencil: £16.50, MAC Cosmetics

For the lazy among us, this is perfect for quick filling-in on the go or when you've overslept. It produces thick, luscious brows with one easy swoop and has an inbuilt sharpener at the end so you'll never be caught without one.

Buy now

The Verdict: Eyebrow pencils

For the lowest price of anything we tested with one of the best finishes, Anastasia's Brow Wiz can't be beaten.

IndyBest product reviews are unbiased, independent advice you can trust. On some occasions, we earn revenue if you click the links and buy the products, but we never allow this to bias our coverage. The reviews are compiled through a mix of expert opinion and real-world testing.

Article bookmarked

Find your bookmarks in your Independent Minds section, under my profile