Sign up to Roisin O’Connor’s free weekly newsletter Now Hear This for the inside track on all things music Get our Now Hear This email for free
In rock music it takes a second to make a tragedy, but decades to make a legend. Of the roll call of musicians morbidly classed as the 27 Club – Amy Winehouse, Jimi Hendrix, Brian Jones, Jim Morrison, Janis Joplin and others who died at music’s cursed age – Kurt Cobain most immediately fit the epithet. Far beyond his unique talents he was a generational icon, the grunge punk pioneer at the epicentre of his entire movement. A figure that encapsulated the early Nineties alternative rock explosion in one defiant-yet-pained gaze into camera and, by being so honest and relatable to his fans, made them feel that they did too.
Listing Nirvana ’s greatest songs to mark the 25th anniversary of Kurt’s suicide, you quickly realise they can’t be separated from the tragedy of his death – his demons sank their claws deep into the following 10 choice tracks. But you’ll also be struck by the wit, vitality, light and affection bubbling beneath their oil-black surfaces. There’s as much celebration as commiseration here, the power and passion of a little group that always will, until the end…
10 best Nirvana songsShow all 10 1 /1010 best Nirvana songs 10 best Nirvana songs 10. You Know You’re Right (2002) That “You Know You’re Right”, recorded in January 1994 and not released until 2002, was Kurt Cobain’s final song gives the track a morbid curiosity, and certainly it slips easily into the top end of their canon thanks to a tone of desolation that fits the narrative of a tortured superstar reaching the bottom of their downward spiral. In fact, the song is open to interpretation: a musical suicide note (“I will crawl away for good”) or a man making peace with his demons (“It’s so warm and calm inside/I no longer have to hide”). An enigma, to the end.
10 best Nirvana songs 9. Come As You Are (1992) Nirvana’s quiet/loud homage to the Pixies often verged on Weird Al pastiche, but Nevermind’s second single “Come As You Are” is evidence that Kurt cribbed even further afield. The riff is such a close homage to Killing Joke’s “Eighties” there were rumours of a lawsuit, but Nirvana’s wasted, nihilistic reworking helped it embed itself into the Nineties.
10 best Nirvana songs 8. Drain You (1991) A Nevermind album track that became a fan favourite, the frantic and askew “Drain You” was written on the spot at Sound Studios, a minor masterpiece of impetuosity. Some have suggested it’s a love song to Courtney Love, whom Kurt had met by this point and, judging by the chorus, they presumably bonded over a bizarre, ritualistic form of meat snogging.
10 best Nirvana songs 7. In Bloom (1992) Just as Kurt always envisaged himself as a major creative force in rock music, he also predicted the jock invasion that would result. Hence the sardonic satire of “In Bloom”, mocking the brainless mainstream rock fan who “likes all our pretty songs… but he don’t know what it means”, even in a track designed to court them. “In Bloom” was Nevermind’s prettiest song – the jocks rightly flocked.
10 best Nirvana songs 6. Sliver (1990) Concocted in a practice session between Cobain, bassist Krist Novoselic and Mudhoney’s Dan Peters, the febrile clash of grunge noise and indie-pop melody that is “Sliver” is as Pixies as Nirvana ever got, and thus worked as a blueprint for their new Nevermind incarnation (as well as Green Day’s entire career). Kurt decided to release it as a non-album warm-up single in 1990, a kind of ultra-pop warning shot for the more hardcore fans of debut album Bleach: “I wanted to write the most ridiculous pop song I had ever written to prepare people for the next album.” Job done.
10 best Nirvana songs 5. About A Girl (1989) Even before “Sliver”, Kurt had given fans glimpses of his inner pop fan, the kid that had liked The Beatles and ABBA just as much as Black Flag. He was worried about putting what he called “a jangly REM type of pop song” onto Bleach but actually presented one of Nirvana’s most enduring tunes, a song about Kurt’s fractured relationship with then-girlfriend Tracy Marander written after a night spent listening to Meet The Beatles on repeat.
10 best Nirvana songs 4. All Apologies (1993) Intended as a gateway into the gnarled undergrowth of third album In Utero for the Nevermind fans that needed their hands held, “All Apologies” actually acted as a reward. Survive the savagery and the final track unfolded like a comforting old-school treat of just the right flavour: melody and meat, wit (“everyone is gay”) and weariness (“married, buried”) and a shrug of semi-atonement for putting more sensitive listeners through the grunge grinder for 40 minutes: “what else could I write?”
10 best Nirvana songs 3. Heart-Shaped Box (1993) A song about children suffering with cancer, being trapped in an emotionally stifling relationship or Courtney Love’s vagina, depending on who you believe, “Heart-Shaped Box” introduced In Utero with a brooding blast of surrealist rock therapy as vital as anything on Nevermind and, with all its imagery of internal organs, cancer-eating and umbilical nooses, a whole lot more visceral.
10 best Nirvana songs 2. Lithium (1992) Hardcore Cobainistas consider “Lithium” his definitive song – a quiet/loud ricochet of fragility and fury that takes in themes of schizophrenia, loneliness, self-hatred, lethargy and mildly scary sex. It actually concerns a man who turns to God when his girlfriend dies, but in splicing manic-depressive imagery with unstable, spasmodic dynamics, “Lithium” is quintessential Nirvana.
10 best Nirvana songs 1. Smells Like Teen Spirit (1991) You know those hipper-than-thou lists that try to make out it’s shallow, ignorant and predictable to rate a band’s culture-defining behemoth of a track as their best? This isn’t that list. Even removed from its impact and overplay as grunge’s “Paradise City”, “…Teen Spirit” remains an elemental force of rock nature, the sound of 15 years of pent-up basement punk anger bursting onto MTV with a riff like a battle cry. Not bad for a song named after a deodorant.
Read our interview with Nirvana's former manager Danny Goldberg, here
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies