Get our free weekly email for all the latest cinematic news from our film critic Clarisse Loughrey Get our The Life Cinematic email for free
Scarlett Johansson has addressed the casting controversies she became embroiled in over the past few years, maintaining that she should be “allowed to play anyone”.
In 2018, the actor stepped down from playing a trans male character in new film Rub & Tug after receiving widespread backlash for the casting decision.
The move angered many trans actors and queer activists, who argued that there was an entire roster of trans male actors to play the role instead of her.
Johansson had earlier acknowledged those who criticised her decision to star in the film with a statement that read: “Tell them that they can be directed to Jeffrey Tambor, Jared Leto, and Felicity Huffman’s reps for comment.”
She later called her comments “insensitive” and said: “Our cultural understanding of transgender people continues to advance, and I’ve learned a lot from the community since making my first statement about my casting.”
Show all 34 1 /3434 actors who regret big roles 34 actors who regret big roles Viola Davis – The Help Viola Davis was nominated for an Oscar for The Help. Yet, the actor deeply regretted playing the maid Aibileen Clark, saying her character’s voice is not heard enough in the final film. "Have I ever done roles that I've regretted? I have, and The Help is on that list," she told The New York Times. "I want to know what it feels like to work for white people and to bring up children in 1963, I want to hear how you really feel about it. I never heard that in the course of the movie.”
Disney
34 actors who regret big roles Megan Fox – Transformers The Transformers franchise may have grossed billions of dollars at the box-office, but critics have never looked kindly upon the films. Neither has Megan Fox, who told Entertainment Weekly that “people are well aware that this is not a movie about acting”. She also previously took aim at director Michael Bay, saying: “He wants to be like Hitler on his sets, and he is, so he's a nightmare to work for.” Fox later retracted the comment, calling it “righteous anger” that should have not been made public.
Paramount
34 actors who regret big roles Katherine Heigl – Knocked Up Knocked Up remains one of Katherine Heigl’s best-known roles, despite the actor having said she found the whole thing “a little sexist". "It paints the women as shrews, as humourless and uptight, and it paints the men as lovable, goofy, fun-loving guys,” she told Vanity Fair. "It exaggerated the characters, and I had a hard time with it, on some days."
Universal Pictures
34 actors who regret big roles Idris Elba – The Wire Few people knew who Idris Elba was before The Wire. Despite the acclaim that came from playing Stringer Bell on the hugely popular crime show, Elba has some regrets. "We're all idolising Stringer Bell, but who are we really idolising?" he asked David Lammy while appearing on James O’Brien’s podcast. "Are we idolising a smart drug dealer or a dumb narcotics dealer? What are we saying here? Is it OK to pump a community full of heroin but because you're smart at it, that makes you cool? That was a problem for me."
HBO
34 actors who regret big roles Harrison Ford – Blade Runner There are famously seven cuts of Blade Runner. One of those features Harrison Ford’s character, Rick Deckard, narrating scenes. Another – the one director Ridley Scott approves of – is bleaker and does not have Deckard explaining events. Ford does not care for either version. "I didn't like the movie one way or the other, with or without,” he said in 2017, before the release of Blade Runner 2049. “I played a detective who did not have any detecting to do. In terms of how I related to the material, I found it very difficult. There was stuff that was going on that was really nuts."
Warner Bros
34 actors who regret big roles Daniel Craig – James Bond For a time, many people were not sure whether Daniel Craig would return as James Bond for the 25th film in the series. "I'd rather break this glass and slash my wrists,” he told Time Out of returning to the role. “No, not at the moment. Not at all. That's fine. I'm over it at the moment. We're done. All I want to do is move on." Apparently a big enough pay cheque got him back in the tuxedo.
Columbia
34 actors who regret big roles Channing Tatum – GI Joe "I'll be honest, I f**king hate that movie,” Channing Tatum said of GI Joe. “I was pushed into doing it. The script wasn’t any good. And I didn’t want to do something that I – that I was a fan of since I was a kid and watched every morning growing up – and didn't want to do something that was, one, bad. And two, I just didn’t know if I wanted to be GI Joe."
Paramount
34 actors who regret big roles Robert Pattinson – Twilight Most actors who regret taking on roles would wait a few years until publicly bemoaning their experience on set. Not Robert Pattinson. Before the final Twilight film was in cinemas, the actor said of playing the vampire heartthrob Edward Cullen: "It’s weird kind of representing something you don't particularly like." A few weeks later, he added how he would have “mindlessly hated" the series had he not appeared in it.
Summit Entertainment
34 actors who regret big roles Jessica Alba – Fantastic Four While superhero movies may now be Oscar Best Picture contenders (Black Panther), there was a time when playing a spandex-wearing vigilante was anything but prestigious. Jessica Alba was one of the first people to jump on the superhero boom of the mid-Noughties, playing Invisible Woman in Fantastic Four. The experience, though, left her wanting to quit acting altogether. "I hated it. I really hated," she told Elle. "I remember when I was dying in Silver Surfer. The director was like, 'It looks too real. It looks too painful. Can you be prettier when you cry? Cry pretty, Jessica'."
Fox
34 actors who regret big roles Ryan Reynolds – Green Lantern Ryan Reynolds has never watched Green Lantern all the way through. That has not stopped the actor being highly critical of the superhero role, going as far as having Deadpool – who he later played – shoot a fictional version of himself in the head for taking on the role. Ouch.
Warner Bros
34 actors who regret big roles Kate Winslet – Titanic Kate Winslet does not mind Titanic as a film. Her performance as Rose is a completely different matter. "Every single scene, I'm like 'really, really? You did it like that? Oh my God’. Even my American accent, I can't listen to it. It's awful," she told the Telegraph. "Hopefully it's so much better now. It sounds terribly self-indulgent but actors do tend to be very self-critical. I have a hard time watching any of my performances, but watching Titanic I was just like, 'Oh God, I want to do that again.'"
20th Century Fox
34 actors who regret big roles Michelle Pheiffer – Grease II “I hated that film with a vengeance and could not believe how bad it was,” Michelle Pfeiffer said of the sequel to Grease. "At the time I was young and didn't know any better." Thankfully, Pfeiffer's nose for a good script improved rapidly, with her next film being Brian De Palma's cult classic Scarface.
Paramount Pictures
34 actors who regret big roles Halle Berry – Catwoman Halle Berry remains one of the few actors to accept her Golden Raspberry award in person. "Thank you so much. I never in my life thought I would be up here,” she told the audience, before spoofing her own Oscar acceptance speech and thanking her manager. "He loves me so much that he convinces me to do projects even when he knows that it is shit." Meeeeeow.
Warner Bros
34 actors who regret big roles Christopher Plummer – The Sound of Music The Sound of Music remains one of the most beloved films of all time. Christopher Plummer, though, hated playing Captain von Trapp. “I think the part in The Sound of Music was the toughest,” he told The Hollywood Reporter. “Because it was so awful and sentimental and gooey. You had to work terribly hard to try and infuse some miniscule bit of humour into it.”
20th Century-Fox
34 actors who regret big roles Ben Affleck – Daredevil Another big-name actor who regrets taking on a mid-Noughties superhero role. Ben Affleck has remained an ardent Daredveil detractor. "Daredevil didn't work at all", the actor told Entertainment Weekly in 2007. “If I wanted to go viral, I would be less polite. That was before people realised you could make these movies and make them well. There was a cynical sense of ‘put a red leather outfit on a guy, have him run around, hunt some bad guys, and cash the cheque’.”
20th Century Fox
34 actors who regret big roles Sylvester Stallone – Stop, or Mom Will Shoot One of Hollywood’s many iconic actors, Sylvester Stallone will always be remembered for both the Rocky and Rambo films. Less so Stop, or Mom Will Shoot, the 1992 buddy-cop comedy that teamed Stallone up with Estelle Getty. Speaking about the film in 2006, he called it “maybe one of the worst films in the entire solar system, including alien productions we’ve never seen.”
Universal Pictures
34 actors who regret big roles Sarah Jessica Parker – Sex and the City 2 Although Sarah Jessica Parker will forever be best known for playing Carrie Bradshaw on Sex and the City, that does not mean she’s not open to criticising the second film. "I can see where we fell short,” she told an audience at Vulture festival. “I understand, I actually get it. I will say, I also understand how much frickin’ money it made. I feel like that is forgotten in the discussion.”
Warner Bros
34 actors who regret big roles Paul Newman – The Silver Chalice Paul Newman had high standards. So much so that, before the release of The Silver Chalice, the Oscar-winning actor took out adverts in the trade press urging people to not watch the television broadcast of the film. He later called it “the worst motion picture produced during the 1950s".
Everett Collection
34 actors who regret big roles Colin Farrell – Miami Vice Few actors are quite as straight talking as Colin Farrell, who said of the 2006 blockbuster Miami Vice: "Miami Vice? I didn't like it so much. I thought it was style over substance and I accept a good bit of the responsibility.”
Universal Picture
34 actors who regret big roles Brad Pitt – The Devil’s Own There are many films Brad Pitt could arguably regret making (the awful 1992 flick Cool World comes to mind), but speaking to Newsweek in 1997, the actor decided to criticise The Devil’s Own. He called the film a "disaster" and "the most irresponsible bit of filmmaking, if you can even call it that, that I've ever seen".
Columbia Pictures
34 actors who regret big roles Jim Carrey – Kick-Ass 2 Following the shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in 2012, Jim Carrey distanced himself from the violent Kick Ass sequel. “I did Kick Ass a month before Sandy Hook and now in all good conscience I cannot support that level of violence,” he wrote on Twitter. “My apologies”.
Universal Pictures
34 actors who regret big roles Zac Efron – High School Musical Most people know Zac Efron as Troy Bolton from High School Musical. Zac Efron, though, wishes you knew him for something else. “I step back and look at myself and I still want to kick that guy’s ass sometimes," he told Men's Fitness. "He’s done some kind of cool things with some cool people – he did that one thing that was funny – but, I mean, he’s still just that f***ing kid from High School Musical."
Disney
34 actors who regret big roles Shia LaBeouf – Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull Indiana Jones fans had high expectations for the fourth film. Many were left feeling disappointed by the science-fiction adventure. "I feel like I dropped the ball on the legacy that people loved and cherished," LaBeouf later told the LA Times. "You get to monkey-swinging and things like that and you can blame it on the writer and you can blame it on Steven [Spielberg]. But the actor's job is to make it come alive and make it work, and I couldn't do it. So that's my fault. Simple."
Paramount Pictures
34 actors who regret big roles Charlize Theron – Reindeer Games Charlize Theron may be one of the most acclaimed actors working today, but that does not mean she has not worked on bad films. One of those was Reindeer Games, co-starring Ben Affleck. “Reindeer Games. That was a bad, bad, bad movie,” she told Esquire in 2007. “But even though the movie might suck, I got to work with John Frankenheimer. I wasn’t lying to myself – that’s why I did it.”
Miramax
34 actors who regret big roles Sally Field – The Amazing Spider-Man The Amazing Spider-Man series, starring Andrew Garfield as the eponymous web-slinger, was supposed to launch a cinematic universe to match the Avengers. There were even rumours of an Aunt May film entering production. Not that the actor who played Aunt May, Sally Field, would have been thrilled by that. “It’s really hard to find a three-dimensional character in it,” she told Howard Stern of playing the character, “and you work it as much as you can, but you can’t put 10 pounds of s**t in a five-pound bag.”
Sony
34 actors who regret big roles George Clooney – Batman & Robin Michael Keaton, Christian Bale, Adam West – some of Hollywood’s best actors have played the Caped Crusader on screen. However, only one wore a suit with Batnipples: George Clooney. “Let me just say that I’d actually thought I’d destroyed the franchise until somebody else brought it back years later and changed it,” he said of the role. “I thought at the time that this was going to be a very good career move. It wasn’t.”
Warner Bros
34 actors who regret big roles Daniel Radcliffe – Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince Daniel Radcliffe was only 11 years old when he was cast as Harry Potter. That has not prevented the actor from looking back at those films with a critical eye. "I'm just not very good in [The Half Blood Prince],” he told Playboy in 2012. “I hate it. My acting is very one-note and I can see I got complacent and what I was trying to do just didn't come across. My best film is the fifth one [Order of the Phoenix] because I can see a progression."
Warner Bros
34 actors who regret big roles Josh Brolin – Jonah Hex Before playing Thanos in Avengers, Josh Brolin portrayed another comic-book character on screen: Jonah Hex. Unlike the Avengers, Hex was not well received by critics – or Brolin himself. "I think it deserved that bashing for reasons that those critics will never know,” he told Total Film in 2014. “We were almost ready to drop [the film] when this kid [director Jimmy Hayward] came up. He was an interesting young guy full of energy and he was obsessed with Jonah Hex. I thought, ‘This is either a really bad decision or a brilliant decision.' [It was] really bad… If I'm ever really rich, I'll do that movie again. Seriously."
Warner Bros
34 actors who regret big roles James Franco – Your Highness Director David Gordon Green, Danny McBride and James Franco struck gold with their stoner-comedy Pineapple Express. Unfortunately, their attempt to make another laugh-out-loud film, Your Highness, was a mess. "Your Highness? That movie sucks," Franco told GQ. "You can't get around that."
Universal Pictures
34 actors who regret big roles Matt Damon – The Bourne Ultimatum Matt Damon’s original Bourne trilogy won plaudits from critics around the world, with the second instalment featuring on The Independent’s “Films to watch before you die” list. The actor, though, has spoken unkindly about the third film, The Bourne Ultimatum, saying the original script, written by director Tony Gilroy, was awful. "It's really the studio's fault for putting themselves in that position," Damon told GQ. "I don't blame Tony for taking a boatload of money and handing in what he handed in. It's just that it was unreadable. This is a career-ender. I mean, I could put this thing up on eBay and it would be game over for that dude. It's terrible. It's really embarrassing. He was having a go, basically, and he took his money and left."
Universal Pictures
34 actors who regret big roles Arnold Schwarzenegger – Red Sonja “It's the worst film I have ever made,” the former Governor of California, Arnold Schwarzenegger, said of the fantasy film Red Sonja. “When my kids get out of line, they're sent to their rooms and forced to watch Red Sonja 10 times. I never had too much trouble with them."
MGM/UA Entertainment Company
34 actors who regret big roles Alec Baldwin – Rock of Ages There are some actors who know they’re making a disaster midway through production. “It was a complete disaster,” Alec Baldwin told The Wrap when asked about Rock of Ages. “A week in you go, ‘Oh God, what have I done?'”
34 actors who regret big roles Bill Murray – Garfield Bill Murray only voiced the beloved cat Garfield because of a misunderstanding: he thought Joel Coen, of the Coen brothers fame, had written the script. In fact, Joel Cohen, whose filmography includes Cheaper by the Dozen, Toy Story, and Monster Mash: The Movie, had. "I was exhausted, soaked with sweat, and the lines got worse and worse. And I said, 'Okay, you better show me the whole rest of the movie, so we can see what we're dealing with,'" he told GQ. "So I sat down and watched the whole thing, and I kept saying, 'Who the hell cut this thing? Who did this? What the f*** was Coen thinking?' And then they explained it to me: it wasn't written by that Joel Coen."
20th Century Fox
34 actors who regret big roles Bob Hoskins – Super Mario Bros Even for video-game adaptations, Super Mario Bros, released in 1993, was a particularly strange film. Asked by The Guardian, "What is the worst job you've done?" "What has been your biggest disappointment?" and "If you could edit your past, what would you change?" the actor had only one answer: "Super Mario Brothers."
Buena Vista Pictures Distribution
Now, in a new interview with As If Avengers: Endgame now claiming has been “edited for clickbait” – said: “You know, as an actor I should be allowed to play any person, or any tree, or any animal because that is my job and the requirements of my job.”
“I feel like it’s a trend in my business and it needs to happen for various social reasons, yet there are times it does get uncomfortable when it affects the art because I feel art should be free of restrictions,” Johansson continued, adding that “society would be more connected if we just allowed others to have their own feelings and not expect everyone to feel the way we do”.
Just one year earlier, criticism was sparked upon the announcement Johansson was to play the lead in a live-action version of Japanese anime Ghost in the Shell fans accused it of being another example of Hollywood “whitewashing”.
In Marie Claire ’s March cover interview
Watch Apple TV+ free for 7 days New subscribers only. £8.99/mo. after free trial. Plan auto-renews until cancelled
Try for free Watch Apple TV+ free for 7 days New subscribers only. £8.99/mo. after free trial. Plan auto-renews until cancelled
Try for free Earlier this week, Johansson’s Avengers salary was revealed. The staggering amount ranks her among the top five highest-paid Hollywood stars for her role of Black Widow in the Marvel Cinematic Universe .
You can find a ranking of every Avengers character – from worst to best – here and a list of every new Marvel film expected to be released over the next decade here .
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies